home    about    browse    search    latest    help 
Login | Create Account

Review of perspectives applied in the assessment of organic food networks

Thorsøe, Martin H.; Alrøe, Hugo Fjelsted and Noe, Egon (2012) Review of perspectives applied in the assessment of organic food networks. In: Proceedings 10th International Farming Systems Association Symposium.

[thumbnail of 22036.pdf]
Preview
PDF - English
283kB

Document available online at: http://ifsa.boku.ac.at/cms/fileadmin/Proceeding2012/IFSA2012_WS6.1_Thorsoe.pdf


Summary

Value is a key concept for understanding how organic food networks function because values are the foundation of the organic production practice, thus value must be given a significant role in assessing and balancing the effects of organic food networks. At the same time value is a loose concept, widely used and with various meanings in different scientific perspectives, in which ontological difference produces different perceptions of what values are. Assessing organic food networks is thus a complicated process, since the perspective which is chosen has important implications for the analysis and for the outcome of the assessment. This paper reviews five perspectives which predominate in the assessment of food networks, 1) Food Science, 2) Discourse Analysis, 3) Phenomenology, 4) Neoclassical Welfare Economics and 5) ANT. The perspectives are compared with regards to how the food network is assessed, how value is measured and how organic is understood. It is concluded that the perspectives focus analytically on different aspects of the same phenomena and differ in terms of where value is found, but also in the degree of reductionism applied, which factors are included in the analysis and whether or not the analysis focuses on the individual actors or the network as a whole.


EPrint Type:Conference paper, poster, etc.
Type of presentation:Workshop
Keywords:Values, organic farming
Subjects: Knowledge management > Research methodology and philosophy > Specific methods > Indicators and other value-laden measures
Knowledge management > Research methodology and philosophy
Values, standards and certification > Evaluation of inputs
Research affiliation: Denmark > Organic RDD 1 > MultiTrust
Related Links:http://ifsa2012.dk/?page_id=792
Deposited By: Thorsøe, Postdoc Martin
ID Code:22036
Deposited On:20 Dec 2012 08:13
Last Modified:10 Feb 2015 10:07
Document Language:English
Status:Published
Refereed:Peer-reviewed and accepted
Additional Publishing Information:Contributing to MultiTrust Deliverables 3.1.1 and 3.3.1

Repository Staff Only: item control page