creators_name: Anon, 
type: report
datestamp: 2006-04-07
lastmod: 2009-08-20 14:31:45
metadata_visibility: show
title: Improving N use and performance of arable crops on organic arable farms using an expert group approach (OF0178)
ispublished: pub
subjects: 4nutrient
subjects: 5transfer
subjects: 3compost
full_text_status: public
keywords: nitrogen, crops, rotations, case study, manure, soil nutrients, potassium, phosphorus, knowledge transfer, water pollution, OF0178
abstract: This is the final report for Defra project OF0178.
Government seeks to support the development of organic farming in the UK, but nitrogen (N) almost always limits productivity on organic farms.  This project devised guidance by which farmers could manage N to best effect on organic land.  ‘Experts’ in i) organic farming systems, ii) manure management, iii) N cycling in farming systems and iv) crop N responses and N fixation, working through Case Studies representing arable and mixed organic systems and reviewing relevant literature, devised changes which would a) increase the availability of N for crop uptake, b) decrease losses of N to the environment, and c) be acceptable to farmers. 
Nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) budgets were calculated for 9 organic Case Study farms in the UK.  The farms were on sandy loam, silt clay loam and silt loam over chalk soil types and included stockless rotations and cattle, pig and poultry enterprises with a significant proportion of cropping. A soil surface nutrient budget was calculated for the target rotation on each farm using information about field management and measurements of the soil, crops and manure. Losses of N through leaching and volatilization were calculated independently using the NITCAT and MANNER models. 
The budgets calculated for these Case Studies indicated no reason for organic systems to be inherently unsustainable with regard to N, P or K.  Rotations showed a wide range of nutrient balances, with differences arising from contrasting crop sequences, varied interactions with on-farm livestock and use of supplementary nutrients. There is therefore scope to increase the efficiency of individual organic systems and minimise losses to the environment.  Simple rotational budgets, as used in the Case Studies were found to be a useful tool for farmers and their advisors to understand and manage nutrient flows at a rotational level. The results of the Case Study analysis and literature review clearly showed that the supply of available N must be increased during the period of rapid crop growth to improve arable crop productivity in organic systems.
In conclusion, small improvements in efficiency of N retention, redistribution, or relocation were predicted to cause large improvements in output, since the greatest responses in crop production occur at the low levels of N common to organic systems.  These improved management strategies were transferred to the organic farming community, through press articles and presentations to organic farmers, consultants and scientists.
There is a more detailed summary at the start of the main report.
date: 2002
date_type: published
institution: ADAS
department: Boxworth
refereed: never
referencetext: Alderman G & Cottrill BR 1995. Energy and Protein Requirements of Ruminants.  An advisory manual prepared by AFRC Technical Committee on responses to nutrients pp 133-139.
Anon. 2000. Fertilizer Recommendations. (Seventh Edition). MAFF Reference Book 209. HMSO, London.
Baars T 2000. Effective use of manure and fertilizer in organically grown grass/clover swards. In: Grassland farming-balancing environmental and economic demands. Proceedings for the 18th general meeting of the European Grassland Federation, eds K Soegaard C Ohlsson J Sehested NJ Hutchings & T Kristense, pp 524-526.
Bailey RJ & Spackman E 1996. A model for estimating soil moisture changes as an aid to irrigation scheduling, and crop water use studies: I Operational details and description. Soil Use and Management 12, 122-128.
Barnes JP & Putnam AR 1986. Evidence for allelopathy by resides and aqueous extracts of rye. Weed Science 34, 384-390.
Berry PM Griffin JM Sylvester-Bradley R Spink JH Scott RK Clare R & Baker CJ 2000. Controlling plant form through husbandry to minimise lodging in wheat. Field Crops Research 67, 59-81. 
Berry PM Sylvester-Bradley R Philipps L Hatch DJ Cuttle S & Raynes F 2002. Tactical management of nitrogen. Soil Use and Management 18, 1-8.
Bryson RJ Sylvester-Bradley R Scott RK Duffield SJ Clare RW Gay A Stokes DT Young JEB & Hims M 1997. Effects of fertilizer derived changes in structure and composition of winter wheat on population dynamics and thresholds for control of the multi-generation pest, Sitobion avenae (English grain aphid) and a disease Puccinia striiformis (Yellow rust). Report to MAFF for project No. CSA 2149.
Chambers BJ Lord EI Nicholson FA & Smith KA 1999. Predicting nitrogen availability and losses following land application of manures to arable land: MANNER.  Soil Use and Management 15, 137-143.
Clarke J 1999. CAP Reform: Potential for the effects on environmental impact of farming. MAFF report
SA0111.
Cuttle S & Bowling PJ 1999. Nutrient budgets and soil fertility. In: Organic Milk Production: Post-conversion Phase. Part 1. Report to MAFF for project No. OF0113.
Foulkes MJ Sylvester-Bradley R & Scott RK 1998. Evidence for differences between winter wheat cultivars in acquisition of soil mineral nitrogen and uptake and utilization of applied fertilizer nitrogen. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 130, 29-44.
Godden B & Pennickx M 1997. Management of farmyard manure composting is important to maintain
sustainability in organic farming. In: Resource Use in Organic Farming. Proceedings of the 3rd ENOF workshop, eds J Isart & JJ Llerena. Ancona pp 225-232.
Gooding MJ Cannon ND Thompson AJ & Davies WP 1999. Quality and value of organic grain from contrasting bread making wheat varieties and near isogenic lines differing in dwarfing genes. Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 16, 335-350.
Goulding KWT & Loveland PJ 1987. The classification and mapping of potassium reserves in soils of England and Wales. Journal of Soil Science 37, 555-565. 
Goulding KWT 1990.  Nitrogen deposition from the atmosphere. Soil Use and Management 6, 61-63. 
Goulding KWT Bailey NJ & Bradbury P 1998a. A modelling study of nitrogen deposited to arable land from the atmosphere and its contribution to nitrate leaching. Soil Use and Management 14, 70-77. 
Goulding KWT Bailey NJ Bradbury P Hargreaves P Howe M Murphy DV Poulton PR & Willison TW 1998b. Nitrogen deposition and its contribution to nitrogen cycling and associated soil processes.  New Phytologist 139, 49-58.
Henrikson TM Korsoeth A & Eltun R 2000. Impact of incorporation time on the residual N effect of a clover sub crop. Proceedings of the 13th international IFOAM conference, the world grows organic, eds T Alfoldi W Lockertz & U Niggli, Basel pp 76.
Hermansen JE & Kristensen T 1998. Research and evaluation of mixed farming systems for ecological animal production in Denmark. In: Mixed Farming Systems in Europe, eds H Van Keulen EA Lantinga & HH Van Laar. Dronten, The Netherlands pp 97-101.
Jarvis SC 1993.  Nitrogen cycling and losses from dairy farms.  Soil Use and Management 9, 99-105.
Jenkinson DS 1985. How straw incorporation affects the nitrogen cycle. In: Straw, soils and science, ed J Hardcastle, AFRC London pp 14-15.
Kaffla S & Koepf HH 1989. A case study in the nutrient regime in sustainable farming. Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 6, 89-106.
Kirchmann H 1989. A 3-year N balance study with aerobic, anaerobic and fresh 15N-labelled poultry manure.  In: Nitrogen in organic wastes applied to soils, eds JA Hansen & K Henriksen, Academic Press London pp 113-125.
Kopke U 1987. Sybiotische Stickstoff-Fixierung and Vorfuchtirkung von Ackerbohnen (Vicia faba L.). Habilitation Thesis University of Gottingen. 
Kristensen ES Hogh-Jensen H & Kristensen IS 1995.  Estimation of biological N2 fixation in a clover grass system by the 15N dilution method and total N difference method.  Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 11, 203-219.
Le Gouis J Beghin J Heamez E & Pluckard P 2000. Genetic differences for N uptake and utilisation efficiencies in winter wheat. European Journal of Agronomy 12, 163-173.
Lord EI 1992. Modelling of nitrate leaching. Aspects of Applied Biology 30, 19-28.
Nolte C & Werner W 1994. Investigations on the nutrient cycle and its components of a biodynamically-managed farm. Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 10, 235-254.
Schmidt H Philipps L Welsh JP & Fragstein P von. 1999.  Legume breaks in stockless organic farming rotations: Nitrogen accumulation and influence on the following crops.  Biological Agriculture and Horticulture 17, 159-170.
Scholefield DR, Lockyer DR Whitehead DC and Tyson KC. 1991.  A model to predict transformations 
and losses of nitrogen in UK pastures grazed by beef cattle. Plant and Soil, 132, 165-177.
Shepherd MA Bhogal A Lennarttson M Rayns F Jackson L Philipps L & Pain B. 1999. The environmental impact of manure use in organic farming. Report to MAFF for Project No. OF0161. 
Smith KA Charles DR & Moorhouse D 2000. Nitrogen excretion by farm livestock with respect to land spreading requirements and controlling nitrogen losses to ground and surface waters. Part 2: Pigs and poultry.  Bioresource Technology 71, 183-194.
Sommer SG & Hutchings NJ 1997.  Components of ammonia volatilization from cattle and sheep production.  In: Gaseous nitrogen emissions from grasslands, eds SC Jarvis & BF Pain, CAB International Wallingford UK pp 79-94.
Sommer SC 2001. Effect of composting on nutrient loss and nitrogen availability of cattle deep litter. European Journal of Agronomy 14, 123-133.
Stokes DT Scott RK Tilston CH Cowie G & Sylvester-Bradley R 1992. The effect of time of soil disturbance on nitrate mineralization. Aspects of Applied Biology 30, 279-282.
Stopes C Millington S & Woodward L 1996. Dry matter and nitrogen accumulation by three leguminous green manure species and the yield of a following wheat crop in an organic production system. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 57, 189-196.
Sylvester-Bradley R & Cross RB 1991. Nitrogen residues from peas and beans and the response of the following cereal to applied nitrogen. Aspects of Applied Biology 27, 293-298.
Thomas C, Reeve A & Fisher 1991. Milk from grass. Grassland Research Institute Hurley UK.
Watson CA Myrbeck A Løes A-K Salomon E Schroder J Bengtsson H & Stockdale EA 2002. A review of farm-scale nutrient budgets for organic farms in temperate regions. Soil Use and Management (in press)
Webb J Harrison R & Ellis S 2000. Nitrogen fluxes in three arable soils in the UK. European Journal of Agronomy 13, 207-233.
Webb J Whinham N & Unwin RJ 1990. Response of cut grass to potassium and to mineral sylvinite. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 53, 297-312.
Younie D & Baars T 1997. Resource use in organic grassland. The central bank and art gallery of organic farming. In: Resource Use in Organic Farming. Proceedings of the 3rd ENOF workshop, eds J Isart & JJ Llerena, Ancona pp 43-60
citation: Anon, (2002) Improving N use and performance of arable crops on organic arable farms using an expert group approach (OF0178).
document_url: http://orgprints.org/8066/2/OF0178_2075_FRP.pdf