creators_name: Adler, Steffen A.
type: thesis
datestamp: 2006-01-10
lastmod: 2009-08-20 14:29:31
metadata_visibility: show
title: Research Design and Communication in Production System Experiments - A Multiple-Case Study in the Nordic Countries
ispublished: unpub
subjects: 2systems
subjects: 6communication
full_text_status: public
keywords: Research design, communication, production system experiment, organic farming, Nordic countries, multiple-case study, survey
abstract: Since the 1980s, production system experiments are a commonly used research strategy in ecological farming in the Nordic countries. This type of experiments fit in under the holistic oriented framework of farming systems research, which was developed in the 1970s as a reaction to the negative impacts of the Green Revolution in developing countries. The approach is to investigate farming systems as a whole and integrate researchers, extensionists and farmers actively in the research design. 

In the Nordic countries, 48 production system experiments are identified in a survey. By using the criteria of 1) research orientation, 2) experimental area, 3) duration and 4) other criteria, the design of the production system experiments could be characterised as more reductionistic or more holistic. 

A qualitative multiple-case study of production system experiments at the research station Apelsvoll (Norway), and the research farms Logården, Öjebyn and Tingvall (all Sweden) was accomplished to relate communication between researcher, extensionist, farmer and consumer back to research design. Both formal and informal communication forms indicate differences in the communication networks of the cases. Apelsvoll has a more reductionistic research design and a hierarchic one-way communication. Tingvall has a holistic full-scale design that includes other actors and a more developed communication network, which is less hierarchic and two-way. Logården and Öjebyn have features of both reductionistic and holistic research design. Also social aspects play an important role for the development of communication channels. 

In the multiple-case study a relation was found between reductionistic research design and a less developed communication network on one hand, and holistic research design and well-developed communication. However, the integrative approach of the Logården project and the Tingvall project is not embedded in the research methodology. New knowledge is needed about ecological farming at a farming systems level, which includes also social aspects. This is necessary to meet rapid changes in social and economical structures on farms and in society in general. 

Insights gained in this study may help to improve the existing research design of ongoing production system experiments and to develop new research strategies under the framework of farming systems research in the Nordic countries. This work may also contribute to more focus on interdisciplinary approaches and closer interaction between existing production system experiments. 
date: 2003-05
date_type: published
institution: Agricultural University of Norway
department: Department of Horticulture and Crop Sciences
refereed: never
referencetext: Andersson, F., Andersson, C., 2002. Personal communication, Tegen, Tanumshede, Sweden, 1st November, 12.30-13.30. Tel. +46 525-502 27. 
Andersson, H.-E., 2002. Personal communication, Skara, Sweden, 30th October, 9.30-10.30. Mobil +46 70 572 990 25. 
Andreasen, C.B., Oudshoorn, F.W., 1999. Den økologisk forsøgsstation på Rugballegård. Forskningsnytt om økologisk landbruk i Norden, Nr. 1, pp. 10-12. 
Anonymous, 2003. Personal communication. Farm in the County of Oppland, Norway, 20th February, 12.30-13.30. 
Arnesson, A., 2002. Personal communication, Skara, Sweden, 30th October, 13.00-14.00. Tel. +46 511-671 37. 
Bakken, A.K., Asdal, Å., Sveistrup, T., 2001. Dyrkingssystemene på Kvithamar og Landvik. In: Abrahamsen, U. (Ed.), Jord- og Plantekultur 2001, pp. 324-328. 
Bawden, R.J., Ison, R.L., 1992. The purpose of field-crop ecosystems: social and economic aspects. In: Pearson, L.J. (Ed.), Field-crop ecosystems of the world, Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 11-35. 
Bergström, S., Ekre, E., 2001. Mellbyförsöken 1990-2000. Hushållningssällskapet Halland/Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. 
Biggs, S., Farrington, J., 1991. Agricultural research and the rural poor: a review of social science analysis. International Development Research Centre, Ottawa, Canada, 139 pp. 
Boström, U. (Ed.), 2002. Placering av försök inom Programmet SLUs ‘Ekoforsk’ 2002. Fältforskningsenheten, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, 22 pp. 
Checkland, P., 1981. Systems thinking, systems practice. John Wiley & Sons Ldt., Brisbane, 330 pp. 
Christensen, B.T., Petersen, J., Kjellerup, V., Trentemøller, U., 1994. The Askov long-term experiments on animal manure and mineral fertilizers: 1894-1994. Danish Institute of Plant and Soil Science. SP report, Nr. 43 (2), 85 pp. 
CUL, 2002. Aktiviteter på Ekhaga försöksgård, Ekhaga 2002. Centre for Sustainable Agriculture (CUL), Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. 
Deffontaines, J.P., 1993. The farm field, a focus for interdisciplinary studies from ecophysiology to human sciences. In: Brossier, J., De Bonneval, L., Landais, E. (Eds.), Systems studies in agriculture and rural development. A selection of papers published by researchers in the Agrarian Systems and Development Department of INRA (1990-1994). Institut National de Recherche Agronomique, Paris, pp. 19-29. 
Delin, K., 2002. Personal communication, Skara, Sweden, 6th December, 17.30-18.30. Tel. +46 511-248 32. 
Dillon, J.L., Plucknett, D.L., Vallaeys, G.Y., 1978. Farming systems research at the international agricultural research centers. The Consultative Group of International Agricultural Research (CGIAR), Technical Advisory Committee (TAC), TAC secretariat Rome, 197 pp. 
DJF, 2003. Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences. 1st May 2003, http://www.foulum.dk/jbt/Rugballeg_uk/personale_uk.shtml , http://www.agrsci.dk/ifo/markd/Forsogsstationer/Rugballegaard/index.shtml .
Dlouhy, J., 1981. Alternativa odlingsformer – växtprodukters kvalitet vid konventionell och biodynamisk odling. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. Dep. of Plant Husbandry, Uppsala, report 91. 
Doppler, W., 1994. Farming systems approach and its relevance for agricultural development in central and Eastern Europe. In: Dent, J.B., McGregor, M.J. (Eds.), Rural and farming systems analysis: European perspectives. CAB International, UK, pp. 65-77. 
DST, 2003. Statistics Denmark, 1st May 2003, http://www.dst.dk 
Ekeberg, E., 1997. Langvarige gjødslingsforsøk på Møystad, Vang Hedmark. In: Abrahamsen, U. (Ed.), Jord- og Plantekultur 1997, Nr. 4, pp. 194-204. 
Ekeberg, E., Riley, H., 1995. The long-term fertilizer trials at Møystad, S.E. Norway. In: Christensen B.T., Trentemøller, U. (Eds.), The Askov long-term experiments on animal manure and mineral fertilizers. Danish Institute of Plant and Soil Science, SP report, Nr. 29, pp. 83-97. 
Eltun, R., Korsæth, A., Nordheim, O., 2002. A comparison of environmental, soil fertility, yield, and economical effects in six cropping systems based on an 8-year experiment in Norway. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 90(2), 155-168. 
Eneroth, B., 1984. Hur mäter man vackert? Grundbok i kvalitativ metod. Natur och Kultur, Göteborg, 179 pp. 
Eriksson, K., Helander, C.A., Lidberg, J., 1999. Ekologisk odling på Logården 1992-1998. Hushållningssällskapet Skaraborg, HS report, Nr. 1. 
Fagerberg, B., Salomon, E., Jonsson, S., 1996. Comparisons between conventional and ecological farming systems at Öjebyn, nutrient flows and balances. Swedish Journal of agricultural Research, 26, pp. 169-180. 
FFE, 2003. Fältforskningsenheten, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. 1st may 2003, http://www.ffe.slu.se 
FØJO 2003. Forskningscenter for Økologisk Jordbrug (Danish Research Centre for Organic Farming). 1st may 2003, http://www.agrsci.dk/foejo/forskning/foejoii/iv.html 
Gesslein, S., 1988. Utlakning av kväve m.m. i Bjärrödsförsöken. Skånskt lantbruk, Hushållningssällskap Kristianstads län and Hushållningssällskap Malmöhus län. 
Gesslein, S., 1995. Resultat från försöken med olika odlingssystem på Bjärröd. Hushållningssällskap Kristianstads län and Hushållningssällskap Malmöhus län. Skånskt lantbruk, Nr. 2. 
Gibbon, D., 1994. Farming systems research/extension Background concepts, experience and networking. In: Dent, J.B., McGregor, M.J. (Eds.), Rural and farming systems analysis: European perspectives. CAB International, UK, pp. 3-18. 
Gunnarsson, A., Nilsson, H., Stenberg, B., Nilsson, C., Pettersson P., Sönne, B., 1994. Försök med olika odlingsformer. Miljöprojekt inom Kristianstads läns landsting. Rapport för åren 1987-1992. Meddelande från Södra jordbruksförsöksdistriktet SLU, Södra jordbruksförsöksdistriktet, Nr. 41. 
Guzmán, E.S., ISEC team, 1994. The role of farming systems research/extension in guiding low input systems towards sustainability: An agroecological approach for Andalusia. In: Dent, J.B., McGregor, M.J. (Eds.), Rural and farming systems analysis: European perspectives. CAB International, UK.
HAGSTOFA, 2003. Statistics Iceland, 1st May 2003, http://www.hagstofa.is 
Hannukkala, A.O., Korva, J., Tapio, E., 1990. Conventional and organic cropping systems at Suitia I: Experimental design and summaries. Journal of agricultural science in Finland, 62, 295-307. 
Haraldsen, T.K., Asdal, Å., Nesheim, L., Ugland, T.N., 2000. Nutrient Balances and yield during conversion from conventional to organic cropping systems on silt loam and clay soils in Norway. Biological Agriculture and Horticulture, 17, 229-246. 
Helander, C.-A., 1998. Resurshushållande växtodlingssystem – Logårdsprojektet Regional växtodlings- och växtskyddskonferens. Uddevalla 14-15 jan. 1998, Institutionen för jordbruksvetenskap Skara, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. 
Helander, C.-A., 2002a. Farming systems research: an approach to developing of sustainable farming systems and the role of white clover as a component in nitrogen management. Doctoral thesis, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Agraria 334. 
Helander, C.-A., 2002b. Personal communication, Skara and Logården, Sweden, 29th October, 9.00-12.30. Tel. +46 511-248 15. 
Hill, J., 2002. Personal communication, Skara, Sweden, 29th October, 13.00-14.00. Tel. +46 501-60 58 24. 
HS, 2003a. Hushållningssällskapet Halland, Sweden, 1st may 2003, http://www.hush.se/o/tingvall/ .
HS, 2003b. Hushållningssällskapet Halland, Sweden, 1st may 2003, http://www.hush.se/l/fastigheter/sandbygard.htm, http://www.hush.se/l/fastigheter/hillshog.htm 
HS, 2003c. Hushållningssällskapet Halland, Sweden, 1st may 2003, http://www.hush.se/r 
Hultman, B., 2002. Personal communication, Öjebyn, Sweden, 11th October, 13.00-14.30. Tel. +46 911-607 96. 
IJV, 2003. Institutet för Jordbruksvetenskap, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Skara (Department of Agricultural Research), 1st may 2003, http://www.jvsk.slu.se/le/lanna/lanna1.htm 
Jensen, E.S., 2001. Bakkegården – KVL’s økologiske undervisnings-, forsknings og demonstrasjonsgård. Prosjektbeskrivelse. Center for Økologi og Miljø, 25 pp.
Jonsson, S. 1994a. Research-station of Öjebyn. In: Granstedt, A. and Koistinen, R. (Eds.), Converting to organic agriculture. Proceedings of NJF-seminarium no 237, St Michel, Finland, 22-24 March 1994, NJF-utredning/report Nr. 93, pp. 108-110. 
Jonsson, S., 1994b. Forskningsstationen i Öjebyn, Ekologiskt lantbruk, Nr. 17. 
Jonsson, S., 2002. Personal communication, Öjebyn, Sweden, 10th October, 10.00-14.00. Tel. +46 911-661 00. 
Jonsson, S., 2003. Personal communication, 2nd May, simon.jonsson@njv.slu.se . 
Kahiluoto, H., 1990. Working situation for ecological agriculture in Finland. Alternativ odling Nr. 5. 
Kahiluoto, H., 2002. Personal communication, 31st January 2003, kahiluot@mappi.helsinki.fi .
Karlsson, L., 1992. Ekhaga. Ekologiskt lantbruk inför framtiden – Konferens 1991, Ekologiskt lantbruk, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Avdelningen för ekologiskt lantbruk, Nr. 13. 
Kjellenberg. L., Granstedt, A., 1998. Mark, gröda, gödsling. Resultat från K-försöket. En 33-årig studie av gödslingens inverkan på mark och grödors egenskaper. Studien genomförd 1985-1990 av Bo D. Pettersson. Biodynamiske forskningsinstitutet. Levande kunskap Stockholm, 1 (36), 109 pp. 
Korsæth, A., 2003. Personal communication, Kise, Norway, 20th February, 9.00-10.30. Tel. +47 61 16 69 10. 
Korsæth, A., Eltun, R., 2000. Nitrogen mass balances in conventional, integrated and ecological cropping systems and the relationship between balance calculations and nitrogen runoff in an 8-year field experiment. Agriculture, Ecosystem and Environment 79 (2-3), 199-214. 
Korsæth, A., Eltun, R., Nordheim, O., 2001. Forandring av forsøksplanen for dyrkingssystemene på Apelsvoll. In: Abrahamsen, U. (Ed.), Jord- og Plantekultur 2001, pp. 316-323. 
Kvale, S., 1996. InterViews: An introduction to qualitative research interviewing. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, California, 326 pp. 
Kvinnerstaskolan, 2003. Kvinnerstaskolan. 1st May 2003, www.kvinnersta.orebro.se 
KVL, 2003. The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Denmark. 1st May 2003, www.agsci.kvl.dk 
Lagerrot, N., 1992. Tingvall Ekologiskt lantbruk SLU, Avdelningen för ekologiskt lantbruk, Nr. 13 Ekologiskt lantbruk inför framtiden - Konferens 1991. 
L-Baeckström, G., 1998. T län Kvinnerstaskolan Ekologiskt lantbruk. Forsknings- och utvecklingsprojekt, försöksgårdar och skoljordbruk i Sverige 1998, Centre for Sustainable Agriculture, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. 
LFR, 2003. The Norwegian Agricultural Extension Service. 1st May 2003, www.lfr.no 
Lier, S., 2003. Personal communication, Blæstad, Hamar, Norway, 21st February, 9.00-10.00. Tel. +47 62 54 16 33. 
Ljung, M., 1998. The study circle: A method in environmental work. In: A Markey et al. (Ed.), The challenge for extension education in a changing rural world. Proceedings from the 13th European Seminar on Extension Education, 1998, Dublin, Irland, pp. 310-316.
Løes, A.-K., Schmidt, K.G., 1993. Hva var 30 bruks-prosjektet? En beskrivelse av prosjektforløp og resultater. Norsk senter for økologisk landbruk, Tingvoll, 51 pp. 
Mäder, P., Fliessbach, A., Dubois, D., Gunst, L., Fried, P., Niggli, U., 2002. Soil fertility and biodiversity in organic farming. Science 296, 1694-1697. 
Martin, R.J., Cornish, P.S., Verrell, A.G., 1996. An integrated approach to link farming systems research, extension co-learning and simulation modelling. Proceedings of the 8th Australian Agronomy Conference, Toowoomba, 1996. 
McClure, G.D., 1991. An integrated communication system for technology transfer: the CTTA project. Chapter 16. In: Rivera, W.M., Gustafson, D.J. (Eds.), Agricultural extension: worldwide institutional evolution & forces for change. Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. Amsterdam, pp. 175-187. 
Nilsson, J.G., 2002. Personal communication, Öjebyn, Sweden, 10th October, 14.00-16.00. Tel. +46 920-962 69. 
Njøs, A., 1993. Betydningen av fastliggende, langvarige forsøk. Norwegian agricultural Research, supplement Nr. 16 1993, Jordas produktivitet i langsiktig perspektiv, Statens Fagtjeneste for Landbruket, Ås. 
Norges Vel, 2003. Det Kongelige Selskap for Norges Vel (The Royal Norwegian Society for Development). 1st May 2003, www.norgesvel.no 
OCW, 2003. Organic Centre Wales, 1st May 2003, http://www.organic.aber.ac.uk/statistics/euroarea.htm 
Olesen, J.E., Askegaard, M., Rasmussen, I.A., 2000. Design of an organic farming crop-rotation experiment. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica. Section B, Soil and Plant Science 50, 13-21. 
Olofsson, D., Olofsson, N., 2002. Personal communication, DiNi-Farmen, Sikfors, Sweden, 11th October, 12.00-13.00. Tel. +46 911-701 89. 
Olrog, L., 2002. Personal communication, Tingvall farm, Tanumshede, Sweden, 1st November, 9.30-10.30. Tel. +46 524-282 00. 
Olrog, L., Arnesson, A., Johansson, B., 2002. Ekologisk drift på tingvall 1990-2002: Växtodling och mjölkproduktion. Hushållningssälskapet Göteborg och Bohuslän, 55 pp. 
Østergaard, E., Lieblein, G., 1994. Converting to ecological agriculture in practice and research, a human centred approach. In: Granstedt, A. and Koistinen, R. (Eds.), Converting to organic agriculture. Proceedings of NJF-seminarium no 237, St Michel, Finland, 22-24 March 1994, NJF-utredning/report Nr. 93, pp. 128-135. 
Oudshoorn, F., Kristensen, I.S., 1999. Crop yields from three organic farm systems at Rugballegaard. In: Olesen, J.E., Eltun, R., Gooding, M.J., Jensen, E.S., Køpke, U., (Eds.), Designing and testing crop rotations for organic farming. Proceedings from an international workshop. pp. 141-148. 
Petheram, R.J., Clark, R.A., 1998. Farming systems research: relevance to Australia. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 38, 101-115. 
Poutala, R.T., Kuoppamäki, O., Korva, J., Varis, E., 1994. The performance of ecological, integrated and conventional nutrient management systems in cereal cropping in Finland. Field Crops Research 37, 3-10. 
Rasmussen, J., 2003. Personal communication. 15th May 2003. Jesper.Rasmussen@agsci.kvl.dk .
Rhoades R.E. 1984. Breaking new ground: Agricultural anthropology. International Potato Center, Lima, Peru 84 pp. 
Riley, H., 2003. Personal communication. April 2003, Hugh.riley@planteforsk.no .
Rinne, S.L., Rinne, K., 1986. Skördenivå och skördens kvalitet vid en självförsörjande växtföljd. Nordiska Jordbruksforskares förening (NJF), Odlingssystem och växtföljder med huvudvikt på alternativ odling. 
Röling, N., de Jong, F., 1998. Learning: shifting paradigms in education and extension studies. Journal of Agricultural Extension 5 (3), 143-161. 
SCB, 2003. Statistics Sweden, 1st May 2003, http://www.scb.se 
Schiere, J.B., Lyklema, J., Schakel, J., Rickert, K.G., 1999. Evolution of farming systems and system philosophy. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 16, 375-390. 
Schjønning, P., Elmholt, S., Munkholm, L.J., Debosz, K., 2002. Soil quality aspects of humid sandy loams as influenced by organic and conventional long-term management. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 88, 195-214. 
Shaner, W.W., Philipp, P.F., Schmehl, W.R., 1982. Farming Systems Research and Development: A guideline for developing countries. Westview Press. Boulder. 
Spedding, C., 1994. Farming systems research/extension in the European context. In: Dent, J.B., McGregor, M.J. (Eds.), Rural and farming systems analysis: European perspectives. CAB International, UK, pp. 46-52. 
SSB, 2003. Statistics Norway, 1st May 2003, http://www.ssb.no 
STAT, 2003. Statistics Finland, 1st May 2003, http://www.stat.fi 
Steiner, R.A., 1995. International experience with long-term agricultural experiments. In: Christensen, B.T., Trentemøller, U. (Eds.), The Askov long-term experiments on animal manure and mineral fertilizers: 100th Anniversary Workshop, Askov Experimental Station, 8th-10th September 1994. SP report Nr. 29, 188 pp. 
Thomsen, I.K., Christensen, B.T., 1998. Cropping system and residue management effects on nitrate leaching and crop yields, Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 68 (1-2), 73-84. 
Thuen, E., 1994. Milk production in an ecological farming system. In: Granstedt, A. and Koistinen, R. (Eds.), Converting to organic agriculture. Proceedings of NJF-seminarium no 237, St Michel, Finland, 22-24 March 1994, NJF-utredning/report Nr. 93, pp. 111-116. 
Torstensson, G., 1997. Ekologisk odling – utlakningsrisker och kväveomsättning. Sammanfattning av resultat från den första växtföljdsperioden 1991-1996. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Institutionen för markvetenskap, avd. för vattenvårdslära. Teknisk rapport Nr. 36. 
Torstensson, G., 2000a. Delrapport 1: Modellberäkningar baserade på försöksmaterial från Bollerup och Önnestad i Skåne. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Institutionen för markvetenskap, avd. för vattenvårdslära. Ekohydrologi, Utredning om effekterna på kväveutlakning vid övergång till ekologisk odling Nr. 56. 
Torstensson, G., 2000b. Delrapport 2: Simulerad kväveutlakning i olika odlingssystem förlagda till Västra Götaland. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Institutionen för markvetenskap, avd. för vattenvårdslära. Ekohydrologi, Utredning om effekterna på kväveutlakning vid övergång till ekologisk odling Nr. 56. 
Torstensson, G., 2000c. Delrapport 3: Modellberäkningar baserade på försöksmaterial från Säby i Uppland. Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Institutionen för markvetenskap, avd. för vattenvårdslära. Ekohydrologi, Utredning om effekterna på kväveutlakning vid övergång till ekologisk odling Nr. 56. 
Torstensson, G., 2000d. Ekologisk odling – utlakningsrisker och kväveomsättning. Odlingssystem med och utan djur, på sandjord i Halland och på lerjord i Västergötland. Meddelande från Södra jordbruksförsöksdistriktet, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Södra jordbruksförsöksdistriktet, Avd. för vattenvårdslära, Rapport från växtodlings- och växtskyddsdagar i Växjö den 6 och 7 december 2000, Nr. 51. 
Torstensson, T., 2002. Personal communication, Ledet, Järpås, Sweden, 29th October, 19.00-20.00. Tel. +46 510-915 63. 
Tripp, R., 1985. Anthroplogy and on-farm research. Human organisation 44 (2), 114-124. 
Vereijken, P., 1992. A methodic way to more sustainable farming systems. Netherlands Journal of Agricultural Science 40, 209-223. 
Vereijken, P., 1996. 3. Testing and improving prototypes. Progress reports of the Research Network on Integrated and Ecological Arable Farming Systems for EU and associated countries (Concerted Action AIR 3 – CT920755). AB-DLO Research Institute for Agrobiology and Soil Fertility, Wageningen. 
Vereijken, P., 1997. A methodical way of prototyping integrated and ecological arable farming systems (I/EAFS) in interaction with pilot farms. European Journal of Agronomy 7, 235-250. 
Vestberg, M., 2003. Personal communication. 4th February 2003, mauritz.vestberg@mtt.fi 
Vestberg, M., Kukkonen, S., Saari, K., Uosukainen, M., 2002. Cropping system impact on soil quality determinants. Agricultural and Food Science in Finland 11, 311-328. 
Wilson, K.K., Morren, G.E.B., 1990. Systems approaches for improvement in agriculture and resource management. Macmillan Publ. New York, 361 pp. 
Yin, R.K., 1994. Case study research, designs and methods. Second edition. Applied social research methods series Vol. 5. Sage publications, Thousand Oaks, California, 171 pp. 

 

citation: Adler, Steffen A. (2003) Research Design and Communication in Production System Experiments - A Multiple-Case Study in the Nordic Countries. Thesis, Agricultural University of Norway, Department of Horticulture and Crop Sciences. [ Unpublished, ]
document_url: http://orgprints.org/6736/1/Adler_2003_M_Sc_thesis.pdf