creators_name: Brandt, Kirsten
creators_name: Mølgaard, Jens Peter
type: journalp
datestamp: 2002-10-08
lastmod: 2009-08-20 14:18:18
metadata_visibility: show
title: Organic agriculture: Does it enhance or reduce the nutritional value of plant foods?
ispublished: pub
subjects: 2security
full_text_status: restricted
keywords: Human health, plant foods, cultivation systems, secondary metabolites
abstract: The possible differences between organic and conventional plant products are examined from the view of possible effects on human health. It is concluded that nutritionally important differences relating to contents of minerals, vitamins, protein and carbohydrates are not likely, primarily since neither of these are deficient in typical first world diets, nor are present levels of pesticide residues in conventional products cause for concern. However, there is reason to believe that contents of many defence related secondary metabolites in the diet are lower than optimal for human health, even for those where too high levels are known to be harmful. High biological activity resulting in adverse effects on growth of animals and children may be directly linked with promotion of longevity. There is ample, but circumstantial, evidence than on average organic vegetables and fruit most likely contain more of these compounds than conventional ones, allowing for the possibility that organic plant foods may in fact benefit human health more than corresponding conventional ones. The authors define testable scientific hypotheses, which should be further investigated to provide more definitive answers to the question.
date: 2001-06
date_type: published
publication: Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture
volume: 81
pagerange: 924-931
refereed: yes
referencetext: 1 Woese K, Lange D, Boess C and Bögl KW, A comparison of organically and conventionally grown foods – results of a review of the relevant literature. J Sci Food Agric 74: 281-293 (1997).
2 Locascio SJ, Wiltbank WJ, Gull DD and Maynard DN, Fruit and vegetable quality as affected by nitrogen nutrition, in Nitrogen in Crop Production, Ed. by Hauck RD. American Society of Agronomy, Madison, pp 617-626 (1984).
3 Heldt HW, Chon CJ, Maronde D, Herold A, Stankovic ZS, Walker DA, Kraminer A, Kirk MR and Heber U, Role of orthophosphate and other factors in the regulation of starch formation in leaves and isolated chloroplasts. Plant Physiol 59: 1146-1155 (1977).
4 Kaack, K., Nielsen, M., Christensen, L.P. & Thorup-Kristensen, K., 2001. Nutritionally important chemical constituents and yield of carrot (Daucus carota L.) roots grown organically using ten levels of green manure. Acta Agric. Scand., Section B 51(3/4), 125-136.
5 Kadam SS, Nerkar YS and Salunkhe DK, Subtoxic effects of certain chemicals on food crops. CRC Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 14: 49-109 (1981).
6 Sengewald E, Investigation of the effect of fertiliser on contents of carotene and vitamin C in spinach (Spinacea oleracea L.) with consideration of the develpomental stage. (Untersuchung über der Einfluss der Düngung auf der Karotin- und Vitamin C-gehalt von Spinat (Spinacea oleracea L.) unter berücksichtigung der Entwicklung). Nahrung 3: 453-456 (1959).
7 Bryant JP, Chapin FS III and Klein DR, Carbon/nutrient balance of boreal plants in relation to vertebrate herbivory. Oikos 40: 357-368 (1983). 
8 Coley PD, Bryant JP and Chapin FS III, Resource availability and plant antiherbivore defense. Science 230: 895-899 (1985).
9 Lorio PL, Growth-Differentiation Balance: A basis for understanding southern pine beetle-tree interactions. For Ecol Man 14: 259-273 (1986). 
10 Herms DA and Mattson WJ, The dilemma of plants: To grow or defend. Quart Rev Biol 67: 283-335 (1992).
11 Koricheva J, Larsson S, Haukioja E and Keinänen M, Regulation of woody plant secondary metabolism by ressource availability: hypothesis testing by means of meta-analysis. Oikos 83: 212-226 (1998).
12 Brandt K, Contents of phenolic secondary metabolites in organically grown wheat leaves as affected by nutrient availability (Næringstilførslens betydning for indholdet af fenoliske sekundære metabolitter i  økologisk dyrkede hvedeblade). Forskningsnytt om økologisk landbruk i Norden 6: 10-11 (1999).
13 Hoffland E, Niemann GJ, van Pelt JA, Pureveen JBM, Eijkel GB, Boon JJ and Lambers H, Relative growth rate correlates negatively with pathogen resistance in radish: the role of plant chemistry. Plant Cell Env 19: 1281-1290 (1996).
14 Pedersen HL, Cover crops and scab resistant apple cultivars (Dækkulturer og skurvresistente æblesorter). Forskningsnytt om økologisk landbruk i Norden 4: 13-16 (2000). 
15 McLaughlin MJ, Parker DR, Clarke JM, Welch RM, Metals and micronutrients - food safety issues. Field Crops Research 60: 143-163 (1999). 
16 Bibak, A, Sturup S, Haahr V, Gundersen P, Gundersen V, Concentrations of 50 major and trace elements in Danish agricultural crops measured by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. 3. Potato (Solanum tuberosum Folva). J Agric Food Chem 47:  2678-2684 (1999).
17 Harborne JB, Labadie R, The comparative biochemistry of phytoalexin induction in plants. Biochem Syst Ecol 27: 335-367(1999). 
18 Heath CH, The enigmatic hypersensitive response: Induction, execution and role. Physiol Molec Plant Path 55: 1-3 (1999).
19 Rymal KS, Chambliss OL, Bond MD. Smith DA,  Squash containing toxic cucurbitacin compounds occurring in California and Alabama. J Food Prot 47: 270-271 (1984).
20 Kano Y, Yamabe M, Ishimoto K, The occurrence of bitter cucumber (Cucumis sativus L. cv. Kagafutokyuri) in relation to pruning, fruit size, plant age, leaf nitrogen content, and rootstock. J Japan Soc Hort Sci 66: 321-329 (1997).
21 Grossmann K, Retzlaff G, Bioregulatory effects of the fungicidal strobilurin kresoxim-methyl in wheat (Triticum aestivum). Pestic Sci 50: 11-20 (1997).
22 Lelley, Effects of chemical weed control in sown cabbage (Über die Bedeutung der Chemischen Unkrautbekampfung bei Kohl-Direktsaat). Nachrichtenblatt des deutschen Pflanzenschutzendienstes 23: 104-106 (1971).
23 Ames BA, Profet M, and Gold LS, Dietary pesticides (99.99% all natural). Proc Nat Acad Science 87: 7777-7781 (1990).
24 Essers AJA, Risk assessment of cassava cyanogens. Seminar on Inherent food plant toxicants, Graz, in Nettox report no 7, ed. by Gry J, Danish Veterinary and Food Administration, Søborg, Denmark (1998).
25 Regulation (EC) No 258/97 of the European Parliament and of the Council, of 27 January 1997, concerning novel foods and novel food ingredients. OJ (Official Journal of the European Communities) L 43, 14.2: 1-6 (1997).
26 Graham S, Toward a dietary control of cancer. Epidemiol Rev 5: 38-50 (1983).
27 Ness AR, Powles JW, Fruit and vegetables, and cardiovascular disease: a review. Int J Epidemiol 26: 1-13 (1997).
28 Williams DE, Wareham NJ, Cox BD, Byrne CD, Hales CN, Day NE, Frequent salad vegetable consumption is associated with a reduction in the risk of diabetes mellitus. J Clin Epidemiol 52: 329-35 (1999).
29 Bradlow HL, Telang NT, Sepkovic DW and Osborne MP, Phytochemicals as modulators of cancer risk. Advances in nutrition and cancer 2, Zappia et al. Eds. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York 207-221 (1999).
30 Broardhurst CL, Polansky MM and Anderson RA, Insulin-like biological activity of culinary and medicinal plant aqueous extracts in vitro. J Agric Food Chem 48: 849-852 (2000).
31 http://biomarkw.csl.gov.uk/
32 Southgate DA, Nature and variability of human food consumption. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 334: 281-288 (1991).
33 McCarter RJ, Role of caloric restriction in the prolongation of life. Clin Geriatr Med 11: 553-565 (1995).
34 McShane TM and Wise PM, Life-long moderate caloric restriction prolongs reproductive life span in rats without interrupting estrous cyclicity: effects on the gonadotropin-releasing hormone/luteinizing hormone axis. Biol Reprod 54: 70-75 (1996).
35 Mawson R, Heaney RK, Zdunczyk Z and Kozlowska H, Rapeseed meal-glucosinolates and their antinutritional effects. 3. Animal growth and performance. Nahrung 38: 167-177 (1994).
36 Waghorn G.C. Effect of condensed tannin on protein digestion and nutritive value of fresh herbage. Proc Austr Soc Anim Prod 18: 412-415 (1990).
37 Council Regulation (EEC) No 2092/91 of 24 June 1991 on organic production of agricultural products and indications referring thereto on agricultural products and foodstuffs (with amendments) OJ (Official Journal of the European Communities) L 198 , 22.07:1 -15 (1991).
38 Offermann F and Nieberg H, Economic performance of organic farms in Europe, Organic Farming in Europe: Economics and Policy Stuttgart-Hohenheim 5: 1-198, (2000).
39 Thorup-Kristensen K, An organic vegetable crop rotation aimed at self-sufficiency in nitrogen, in Designing and testing crop rotations for organic farming, Ed by Olesen JE, Eltun R, Gooding MJ, Jensen ES & Köpke U. DARCOF Report 1:133-140 (1999).
40 Jensen LS, Müller T, Eriksen J, Thorup-Kristensen K and Magid J, Simulation of plant production and N fluxes in organic farming systems with the soil-plant-atmosphere model DAISY, in Designing and testing crop rotations for organic farming, Ed by Olesen JE, Eltun R, Gooding MJ, Jensen ES & Köpke U. DARCOF Report 1: 235-248 (1999) 
41 Justesen U, Knuthsen P and Leth T, Quantitative analysis of flavonols, flavones, and flavanones in fruits, vegetables and beverages by high-performance liquid chromatography with photo-diode array and mass spectrometric detection. J Chromat A 799: 101-110 (1998).
42 van Bruggen AHC, Plant disease severity in high-input compared to reduced-input and organic farming systems. Plant Dis 79: 976-984 (1995). 
43 Sanford LL, Deahl KL, Sinden SL and Ladd TL Jr, Glycoalkaloid contents in tubers from Solanum tuberosum populations selected for potato leafhopper resistance. Am Pot J 69: 693-703 (1992).
44 Levite D, Adrian M and Tamm L, Preliminary results of resveratrol in wine of organic and conventional vineyards. Presentation at 6th International Congress on Organic Viticulture 25-26 Aug. 2000, Basel Switzerland, Proceedings 13th IFOAM Scientific Conference p 83 (2000).

citation: Brandt, Dr. Kirsten and Mølgaard, Dr. Jens Peter (2001) Organic agriculture: Does it enhance or reduce the nutritional value of plant foods? Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 81, pp. 924-931. **
document_url: http://orgprints.org/116/1/organic_food.pdf