creators_name: Fowler, Susan creators_name: Frost, David creators_name: de Carle, Caroline editors_name: Fowler, Susan type: report datestamp: 2007-06-19 lastmod: 2009-08-20 14:36:25 metadata_visibility: show title: Environmental and biodiversity impacts of organic farming in the hills and uplands of Wales ispublished: unpub subjects: 7biodiversity full_text_status: public keywords: environment, hill, upland, biodiversity, agri environment abstract: 1. Organic farming is based on principles of co-existence with natural systems, the minimisation of pollution and damage to the environment, and the promotion of the health of soil, plant and animal to produce healthy food with high standards of animal welfare and respect for the wider social and ecological impacts of the agricultural system. 2. Organic Farming has become an important aspect of EU agri-environment policy. Since the implementation of EC Reg. 2078/92 the EU promotes organic farming explicitly on its positive effects on the environment. 3. The environmental and biodiversity benefits of organic systems in the lowlands for mixed farming is generally accepted (Shepherd, 2003) but similar benefits for upland systems have not been identified. This report has been produced by OCW with funding from CCW to address this gap. Where relevant, means to ensure the beneficial impacts through changes to agri-environment schemes, organic standards, and education and dissemination are identified. 4. Hill and uplands are characterised as areas over 200m above sea level where the physical landscape results in production constraints. 5. Biodiversity losses linked to changes in hill and upland agriculture include the erosion of genetic diversity in farmed livestock and crops as well as in wildlife and flora, a reduction in habitat, soil and wildlife diversity and the loss of local knowledge and farming culture. 6. The organic approach to sustainable agriculture in hill or upland systems is through the use of multi species swards and mixed stocking. 7. The report identifies potential points of difference between organic and conventional management practices with regard to hill and upland farming and highlights research requirements to confirm or explore those potentials. 8. Conventional farms can adopt any or all of the practices of the organic farming system, but the engagement with the entire system and annual inspections are specific to the organic farmer. 9. The impacts are not just determined by the system of organic regulations and but also by the management ability and technical skills of the farmer and workers. 10. The practices on organic livestock farms identified that may differ from conventional and have direct biodiversity or environmental impacts are: lower stocking rates (overall manure loading maximum of 170kg/N/ha/yr); an adjustment of the stocking balance (increasing ratio of cattle to sheep); keeping indigenous breeds and strains adapted to the environmental conditions on the farm; limitation on products to control external parasites; reduction and restriction on the use of prophylactic veterinary medicines; the use of foragebased diets; storage and use of slurries, manures and composts, and constraints on the import and export of nutrients. 11. Organic practices in management of grassland and crops identified that may differ from conventional and have direct biodiversity or environmental impacts are: cessation of N fertiliser use; restriction on P & K use; use of lime to maintain pH; use of clovers and herbs in grass leys; cessation of use of chemical pesticides and all herbicides; mechanical and manual weed control and sensitive and timely cultivations; the use of mixed farm systems and rotations on in-bye land; the use of cover crops and undersowing; the use of green manures. 12. Organic regulations do not require habitat creation, but standards state, “that concern for the environment should manifest”…“in high standards of conservation management throughout the organic holding”. Discussion 13. Apart from practices that impact directly on biodiversity or the environment, each management decision on the farm will have knock-on effects that have their own consequences, for example welfare standards for livestock require bedding materials and greater housing space. 14. Organic farms operating solely in the hills and uplands can only be part of a system. Use of in-bye land or having a relationship with lowland holdings to provide winter-feed and forage is necessary to comply with regulations. This will increase the amount of lowland managed organically, bringing widely recognised environmental benefits. 15. Organic agriculture is, by legal definition, a system of production and is based on principles and uses practices adopted to optimise the health of the system. Any farmer may adopt individual practices, and the Tir Gofal scheme provides an opportunity for farmers to provide positive conservation measures, whether conventional or organic. Farming under the EU Regulation defining Organic farming provides assurance to the end consumer that the system used to produce or process the food product was according to that system. This provides a reliable means for consumers to support a system of agriculture that fits more closely with their expectations than intensive systems. 16. Any advantages of lower stocking rates and mixed stocking will only be maintained while organic farms are viable. Organic labelling provides an opportunity for consumers to make a positive choice for high welfare, environmentally benign systems; however the difficulties of marketing, the lack of consumer awareness of food production issues and unwillingness to pay are barriers to access to premium markets for many producers. Conclusions: 17. The potential benefits of individual practices outlined in the document are often clear, but there are currently few data to confirm the extent of some of the practices that may have most beneficial impact. The need for data on actual practices of the organic farmers in the hills and uplands is therefore highlighted. 18. Few Standards changes are recommended, however the monitoring of derogations to standards and use of restricted veterinary inputs is recommended. 19. Research and development needs, technical, education and dissemination, and agri-environment policy issues which may establish, ensure, or enhance the environmental and biodiversity impacts of organic farming in the hills and uplands are outlined. 20. Infrastructure work to integrate hill and upland and lowland systems is necessary to facilitate organic farming in the uplands; this may assist the viability of lowland organic holdings: the environmental benefits of which are established. date: 2004-03 date_type: published institution: Organic Centre Wales refereed: never referencetext: Adamson, H. F., C. N. R. Critchley and A. E. Moon (2002) Organic Sheep and Beef Production in the Uplands: Vegetation Change in the Redesdale Unit from 1995-2001. ADAS Wales unpublished report for DEFRA. ADAS and EFRC (undated) Managing Manure on Organic Farms. Organic Centre Wales Technical Guide, Aberystwyth. Aitchison, J. (1997) The Common Lands of Wales. A report preapred for CCW. Rural Surveys Research Unit, Institute of Geography and Earth Sciences, University of Wales, Aberystwyth. Alderson, L. (1994) The Chance to Survive. Pilkington Press; Yelvertoft. Allen, T. D. (1995) Environmental Benefits from Grassland Farming. Paper presented at the 'British Grassland Society Occasional Synmposium No. 29', Harrogate. Ardeshir, D. (2003) Monitoring of the Organic Farming Scheme for Wales: Baseline Report 2002. ADAS. Wales. Azeez, G. (2000) The Biodiversity Benefits of Organic Farming. Soil Association. Bristol. Ball, B. C., I. P. McTaggart and C. A. Watson (2002) Influx of organic ley-arable management and afforestation in sandy loam to clay soils on fluxes of N2O and CH4 in Scotland. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 90 305-317. Benton, T. G., Vickery, J.A. & Wilson, J.D. (2003) Farmland biodiversity: is habitat heterogeneity the key? Trends in Ecology & Evolution 18 182-188. Bulluck, L. R. I. (2002) Organic and synthetic fertility amendments influence soil microbial, physical and chemical properties on organic and conventional farms. Applied Soil Ecology 19 (2), 147-160. Chadwick, D. R., R. W. Sneath, V. R. Phillips and B. F. Pain (1999) A UK inventory of nitrous oxide emissions from farmed livestock. Atmospheric Environment 33 (4), 3345-3354. Chambers, B. J., C. N. R. Critchley, J. A. Fowbert, A. Bhogal and S. C. Rose (2000) Soil Nutrient Status and Botanical Composition of Grasslands in Welsh Environmentally Sensitive Areas. ADAS Report on MAFF Project BD1429. Mansfield. Collyer, R. and D. Frost (2002) Tir Gofal and The Organic Farming Scheme - Working Together. Unpublished Report, ADAS. Pwllpeiran. Crutzen, P. J., I. Aselmann and W. Seliler (1986) Methane production by domestic animals, wild ruminants and other herbivorous fauna, and humans. Tellus 38B (3-4), 271-284. Curl, C. L., R. A. Fenske and K. Elgethun (2002) Organophosphorous pesticide exposure of urban and suburban pre-school children with organic and conventional diets. Journal of the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Davies, D. A., & Munro, J.M.M. (1974) Potential pasture production in the uplands of Wales. Nitrogen response from sown and natural pastures. Journal of the British Grassland Society 29 149-158. Davies, E. (1979) Hendre and Hafod in Caernarvonshire. Transactions of the Caernarvonshire Historical Society 40 19-20. Davies, E. (1980) Hafod, Hafoty and Lluest: their distribution, features and purposes. Ceredigion IX 1 DEFRA (2002) Organic Action Plan. DEFRA. London. DoE (1994) Biodiversity:the UK Action Plan. HMSO; London. Dyrmundsson, O. R. (2000) Organic Agriculture under Northern Conditions - Iceland. Paper presented at the '13th International Scientific Conference', Basel. Edwards, M. (2000) Where have all the Bumble-bees gone? Forage Matters, Autumn 2000. EEA (1999) Glossary of terms. 2003. European Environment Agency http://www.glossary.ees.eu.int; Elsen, v. T. (1997) Landschaftsentwicklung - eine Zukunftsaufgabe fur deie okologische Landwirtschaft? Paper presented at the 'Beitrage zur vierten Wissenschaftstagung zum okologischen Landbau', University of Bonn, Germany. Feber, R. E., Johnson, P.J., Firbank, L.G. & MacDonald, D.W. (1997) The effects of organic farming on pest and non-pest butterfly abundance. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 64 133-139. Fertilizer Organisation of Ireland (1999) Lime Recommendations. Factsheet 4. Dublin. Fowler, S., N. Lampkin and P. Midmore (2000) Organic Farm Incomes in England and Wales, 1995/96 -1997/98. Institute of Rural Studies, University of Wales, Aberystwyth. Fowler, S., I. Wynne-Jones and N. Lampkin (2001) Organic farm incomes in England and Wales 1998/99. 2001. Institute of Rural Studies, Aberystwyth; Frame, J. (1996) The effect of fertilizer nitrogen application in spring and/ or autumn on the production from a perennial ryegrass/white clover sward. Recent Research and Development on White Clover in Europe, REUR Technical series 42, Rome: FAO 88-91. Frame, J. and A. G. Boyd (1987) The effect of strategic use of fertilizer nitrogen in spring and/or autumn on the productivity of a perennial ryegrass/white clover sward. Grass and Forage Science 42 429-438. Frieben, B. and U. Kopke (1996) Effects of farming systems on biodiversity. Paper presented at the 'Organic Farming in Land Use Systems: Proceedings of the First Workshop of ENOF', Bonn 1995. Frost, D. (2000) Organic Farming in the Uplands - Appraisal of a Development Programme. Paper presented at the 'British Grassland Society Sixth Research Conference', Aberdeen. Frost, D. (2001) Organic Farming at ADAS Pwllpeiran 1993-2001. ADAS Wales, Pwllpeiran. Frost, D. (2003) A review of the environmental and socio-economic effects of organic farming. ADAS Wales, Pwllpeiran. Frost, D., B. M. L. McLean, J. Oswald and R. Collyer (2002) Information and conversion - OCIS in Wales 1996-2001. 2002. www.organic.aber.ac.uk/library; Fuller, R. J., Firbank, L.G., MacDonald, D., Manley, W. & Wolfe, M.S. (1997) Factors influencing biodiversity within organic and conventional systems of arable farming. Paper presented at the 'Proceedings of 13th International IFOAM', Basel, August 2000. Gibson, C. W. D., Hambler, C. & Brown, V.K. (1992) Changes in spider (Araneae) assemblages in relation to succession and grazing management. Journal of Applied Ecology 29 132-142. Gimingham, C. H. (1989) Heather and heathlands. Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society 101 263-268. Goodwin, M. J., R. J. Parkinson, E. N. D. Williams and J. R. B. Tallowin (1998) Soil phosphorous extractability and uptake in a Cirsio molinietum fen meadow and an adjacent Holcus lanatus pasture on the culm measures. Agriculture,Ecosystems and Environment 70 169-179. Gordon, I. J. (1988) FAcilitation of red deer grazing by cattle and its impact on red deer performance. Journal of Applied Ecology 25 1-10. Greenland, D. (2000) Effects on Soils and Plant Nutrition. In: Shades of Green - A review of UK farming systems. (P. B. Tinker). RASE; Warwickshire, pp Hampicke, U. (1978) Agriculture and conservation - ecological and social aspects. Agriculture and Environment 4 25-42. Hausheer, J., Rogger, C., Schaffner, D., Keller, L., Freyer, B., Mulhauser, G., Hilfiker, J. and Zimmermann, A. (1988) Okologische und produktionstechnische Entwicklung landwirtschaftlicher Pilotbetriebe 1991 bis 1996. Schlussbericht derf Nationalen Projectgruppe Oko-Pilotbetriebe. Haygarth, P. M. and S. C. Jarvis (1999) Transfer of phosphorous from agricultural soils. Advances in Agronomy 66 195-249. Hillman, J. P., J. Hill, J. E. Morgan and J. M. Wilkinson (2003) Recycling of sewage sludge to grassland: a review of the legislation to control of the localization and accumulation of potential toxic metals in grazing systems. Grass & Forage Science 58 (2), 101. Hopkins, A. and J. Tallowin (2002) Enhancing the biodiversity and landscape value of grasslands. In: IGER Innovations. IGER; Aberystwyth, pp Hutton, S. and P. S. Giller (2003) The effects of the intensification of agriculture on northern temperate dung beetle communities. Journal of Applied Ecology 40 994-1007. IFOAM (1998a) Basic standards for organic production and processing. International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements; Tholey-Theley. IFOAM (1998b) IFOAM Basic Standards for Organic Production and Processing. IFOAM Publications; Germany. JNCC (2003) Chemical alternatives to treatment of cattle with Ivermectin Ectoparasite treatment - organophosphates. 2003. Joint Nature Conservancy Council http://www.jncc.gov.uk/species/Factsheets_archives; Kay, S. G., S. (1999) Rare Arable Flora Survey. Northmoor Trust. Keatinge, R. (1996) Controlling internal parasites without anthelmintics (a review). ADAS Redesdale; Newcastle-upon-Tyne. Keatinge, R., G. B. Merrell and J. Elliott (1993) Organic Sheep and Beef Production in the Hills and Uplands. Conversion Report 1991-1993. ADAS Report for MAFF. Kirkham, F. W. (1999) A Literature Review of Factors Influencing the Growth of Heather (Calluna vulgaris). ADAS Final Report MAFF Contract BD0116. Kotschi, J. and K. Muller-Samann (2004) Mitigating Climate Change through Organic Agriculture. Paper presented at the 'Biofach Congress', Nuremberg. Lampkin, N., M. Measures and S. Padel (2002) 2002/03 Organic Farm Management Handbook. University of Wales Aberystwyth/Organic Advisory Service; Aberystwyth/Newbury. MAFF (1998) The soil code. MAFF; London. MAFF (1999) Controlling Soil Erosion - Advice for preventing erosion by water in lowland England. MAFF Publications. London. McConnell, P. (2003) The Agricultural Notebook. Blackwell Publishing; Oxford. McCracken, D. I. (1995) Short note on potential environmental problems of cattle and sheep anthelmintics. Extensive Farming Systems Unit , Join Nature Conservation Committee, Paisley. McCracken, D. I., G. N. Foster and A. Kelly (1995) Factors affecting the size of leatherjackets (Diptera: Tipulidae) populations in pastures in the west of Scotland. Applied Soil Ecology 2 203-213. McGechan, M. B. (2003) Modelling phosphorus leaching to watercourses from extending autumn grazing by cattle. Grass and Forage Science 58 151-159. McHugh, M., T. R. Harrod and R. C. P. Morgan (2003) Research on the quantification and causes of upland erosion. Review report to DEFRA. McLean, B. and D. Frost (2003) Draft report: Controlling Ectoparasites on Welsh Organic Sheep Farms. Organic Centre Wales. Aberystwyth. Midgley, L. (1998) Surveys for water vole in the Canolbarth Forest District. Report for Forest Enterprise, UK. Milne, J. A., R. J. Pakeman, F. W. Kirkham, I. P. Jones and J. E. Hossell (2002) Biomass production of upland vegetation types in England and Wales. Grass and Forage Science 57 373-388. Mitchley, J. (1994) Sward Structure with regard to nature conservation. In: Grassland Management and Nature Conservation. Paper presented at the 'BGS Occasional Symposium No. 28.', Moore-Colyer, R. J. (ed.) (1998) Agriculture and Land Occupation in Eighteenth and Nineteenth Century Cardiganshire. Cardiganshire County History Vol.3 Cardiganshire in Modern Times, University of Wales Press; Cardiff. National Assembly for Wales (2001) Farming for the Future. A new direction for farming in Wales. Government of the National Assembly for Wales; Cardiff. National Assembly for Wales (2002) The Future of Organic Farming in Wales. Agriculture & Rural Development Committee. Cardiff. Newbould, P. (1982) Biological nitrogen fixation in upland and marginal areas of the United Kingdom. In: Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 269. Royal Society of London; London, pp 405-417. NSA National Sheep Association (2003) Response of the National Sheep Association to IEEP: Evaluating the Impacts of Hill Farming in England. NSA. OCW (2003) Organic Farming in Wales 1998-2003. Institute of Rural Sciences, University of Wales. Aberystwyth. Organic Farmers and Growers (2001) Organic Assurance Scheme Control Manual. Organic Farmers and Growers Ltd; Shrewsbury. O'Riordan, T., & Cobb, D. (2001) Assessing the consequences of converting to organic agriculture. Journal of Agricultural Economics 52 (1), 22-35. Padel, S. (2001) Conversion to organic farming: a typical example of the diffusion of an innovation. Sociologia Ruralis 41 (1), 49-61. Pfiffner, L. (1990) Effects of different farming systems on the presence of epigeal arthropods, in particular of carabids (Coloptera:Carabidae) in winter wheat plots. Bulletin de la Societe Entomologique Suisse 63 63-76. Philipps, L., S. Fowler, E. Stockdale and C. Watson (2000) Supplementary nutrients for organic farming: counting the environmental costs. Paper presented at the '13th IFOAM scientific conference.', Basle. Powell, D., S. Walsh and N. Lampkin (1997) Conversion plan for Frongoch Organic Unit. Unpublished report, Institute of Rural Studies, University of Wales,. Aberystwyth. Powell, T. L. (1999) Developing Organic Farming in the Uplands 1998/99. ADAS Wales, Pwllpeiran. Ramesh, P. T., Alfred, R.S., & Gunathilagaraj, K. (1997) Population density of earthworms under different crop ecosystems. Madras Agricultural Journal 84 219-315. Robinson, R. A., J. D. Wilson and H. Q. P. Crick (2001) The importance of arable habitat for farmland birds in grassland landscapes. Journal of Applied Ecology 38 1059-1069. Rundgren, G. (2002) Organic Agriculture and Food Security. IFOAM Dossier 1, IFOAM. Tholey-Theley German. RuralNi (2002) Accessed 28 August 2003. RuralNI @http//www.ruralni.gov.uk; Russell, J. B., F. Diez-Gonzalez and G. N. Jarvis (2000) Effects of Diet Shifts on Escherichia coli in Cattle. Journal of Dairy Science 83 (Symposium: Farm health and safety.), 863-873. Scherz, D. L., & Kemper, W.D. (1994) Crop residue management systems and their role in achieving a sustainable, productive agriculture. Paper presented at the 'ISCO94', New Delhi. Shannon, D., A. M. Sen and D. B. Johnson (2002) A comparative study of the microbiology of soils managed under organic and conventional regimes. Soil Use and Management 18 274-283. Shared Earth Trust (1994) Newsletter 10/October. Shell, D. Y., D. (2001) Organic Beef Production: Two Case Studies of rearing/Finishing Enterprises. In: 2001 Organic Livestock Farming. (D. W. Younie, J.M.). Chalcombe Publications; Lincoln, pp Shepherd, M., B. Pearce, B. Cormack, L. Phillips, S. Cuttle, A. Bhogal, P. Costigan and R. Unwin (2003) An Assessment of the Environmental Impacts of Organic Farming. DEFRA. Sibbald, A. R., J. R. Jones, T. J. Maxwell, J. M. M. Munro, D. A. Davies, M. E. Rees, M. Fothergill and A. J. I. Dalziel (2003) The implications of controlling grazing sward height for the operation and productivity of upland sheep systems in the UK: 6. The effect of reducing stocking rate and application of fertilzer nitrogen in Wales. Grass and Forage Science, 58 77-89. Small, R., C. Poulter, D. Jeffreys and J. Bacon (1999) Towards Sustainable Grazing for Biodiversity. Report No. 316,, English Nature. Peterborough. Soil Association (2000) Standards for Organic Food and Farming. Soil Association; Bristol. Soil Association (2002) Improving biodiversity on organic farms. Technical Guides, Soil Association; Bristol. Stockdale, E. A., N. H. Lampkin, M. Hovi, R. Keatinge, E. K. M. Lennartsson, D. W. MacDonald, S. Padel, F. H. Tatersall, M. S. Wolfe and C. A. Watson (2001) Agronomic and environmental implications for organic farming systems. Advances in Agronomy 70 261-327. Stolton, S. (2002) Organic Agriculture and Biodiversity. IFOAM Dossier 2, IFOAM World Board. Stolze, M., A. Piorr, A. Häring and S. Dabbert (2000) The Environmental Impacts of Organic Farming In Europe. Organic farming in Europe: economics and policy, 6. University of Hohenheim; Hohenheim. Stopes, C., Measures, M., Smith, C. & Foster, L. (1995) Hedgerow management in organic farming - impact on biodiversity. Paper presented at the 'Biodiversity and Land Use: Proceedingss of the First ENOF Workshop', Bonn. Strachan, R. B., L. (1998) Water vole survey of River Teifi 1997-98. WildCRU Report for CCW. Oxford. Strong, L. (1992) Ivermectins: a review of their impact on insects of cattle dung. Bulletin of Entomological Research 82 265-274. Thomas, N. (1999) Living Commons. How improvements in common land management can benefit Wales in the twenty-first century. RSPB, Sandy, Bedfordshire. Thomas, N. (undated) Living fields: policies for a living Welsh countryside in the twenty-first century/Meysydd byw: polisiau ar gyfer cefn gwlad byw yng Nghymru yn yr unfed ganrif ar hugain. RSPB; Sandy. UKROFS (2000) Standards for Food Production: Standards for Organic Livestock and Organic Livestock Products. United Kingdom Register of Organic Food Standards. UKROFS (2001) Standards for Organic Food Production. UK Register of Organic Food Standards; London. Unwin, R., B. Bell, M. Shepherd, J. Webb, R. Keatinge and S. Bailey (1995) The effects of organic farming systems on aspects of the environment. ADAS. London. USDA United States Department of Agriculture (1996) Soil Quality and Resource Management. Tecnical Note 1 Natural Resources Conservation Services. Vereijken, J. F. H. M., &, Baars, T. (1995) Methodological example of landscape development on organic farms, the Goetheanistic approach. Paper presented at the 'Land Use and Biodiversity', Bonn. WAG (2003) An Environmental Strategy for Farming Connect:Draft. Welsh Assembly Government. Cardiff. Wanke, D. (2002) Conservation of livestock genetic resources by targetted on-farm management: a case study of Hinterwalder Cattle in the Southern Black Forest. Paper presented at the 'UK Organic Research 2002', Aberystwyth. Wickramasinge, L. P., S. Harris, G. Jones and Vaughan. N (2003) Bat activity and species richness on organic and conventional farms: impact of agricultural intensification. Journal of Applied Ecology 40 984-993. Wildig, J. (2001) The Mynydd Y Ffynnon Project Final Report. ADAS Pwllpeiran. Wilkins, R. J. and E. A. Garwood (1986) Effects of treading, poaching and fouling on grassland production and utilisation. Paper presented at the 'Grazing. BGS Occasional Symposium No. 19.', Williamson, K. and C. Hall (2003) The hills are alive with . . . water voles. Natur Cymru. A Review of Wildlife in Wales 9 (Winter 2003), WOAD (1999) Welsh Agri: Food Action Plan for the organic sector. Welsh Office Agriculture Department. Cardiff. World Conservation Monitoring Centre (2000) Biodiversity and Climate Change. World Resources Institute (1997) Building Complementaries. Washington DC, USA. Yarwood, R. and N. Evans (2002) Agricultural Biodiversity Resources of Welsh Domestic Livestock. A Report for the Countryside Council for Wales. University of Plymouth. Yeates, G. W., Bardgett, R.D., Cook, R., Hobbs, P.J., Bowling, P.J. & Potter, J.F. (1997) Faunal and microbial diversity in three Welsh grassland soils under conventional and organic management regimes. Journal of Applied Ecology 34 453-470. citation: Fowler, Susan; Frost, David and de Carle, Caroline (2004) Environmental and biodiversity impacts of organic farming in the hills and uplands of Wales. [ Unpublished, ] document_url: http://orgprints.org/10828/1/envimpactsuplands.pdf