home    about    browse    search    latest    help 
Login | Create Account

Evaluation of sustainability in farm and wastewater systems – decision theoretical applications

Refsgaard, Ph. D. Karen (2001) Evaluation of sustainability in farm and wastewater systems – decision theoretical applications. [Vurdering av bærekraftighet i jordbruks- og avløpssystemer - beslutningsteoretiske tilnærmelser.] Thesis, Norges landbrukshøgskole. Now called "Norwegian University of Life sciences", Institutt for økonomi og samfunnsfag. Now called Economics and Resource Management. Doctor Scientiarum theses 2001, no. 5. Agricultural University of Norway.

[img] HTML
12Kb
[img] PDF
748Kb

Online at: http://www.umb.no/ior/publikasjoner/avhandling2001.2.html

Summary

The position taken in this study is that long run sustainability is a complex and context dependent concept, implying that the estimation of value depends on the issues at stake, the decision actors involved and the criteria being emphasised. Sustainability connects the economic process explicitly to the natural environment and the study elucidates how thermodynamics can supplement, although not substitute economic analyses. Both natural and social systems are multidimensional and changes are difficult to assess in a simple, one-dimensional way. The standard assumptions in many decision methods concerning rationality are thus hardly adequate.
The empirical focus is on agricultural production and wastewater handling and in four papers decision supporting tools presuming different types of criteria, scales and degrees of commensurability are analysed. In paper 1, energy utilisation in crop and dairy production systems is analysed through systems modelling showing that variation across different production intensities, thus giving valuable information for the evaluation of the sustainability of various systems. In paper 2, an LP-model is used to find cost-efficient combinations of wastewater systems given a restriction on total pollutant load to a recipient. In paper 3 it is observed that a shift from a household strategy to a recipient strategy is allocatively cost-efficient and increases flexibility. Still the household strategy dominates in praxis. The paper discusses reasons for this i.e., transaction costs, implicit rights modifications and loss aversion. In paper 4, a multicriteria planning model is used to handle value incommensurability when choosing between waste water systems. This is done through an explicit process where different decision actors articulate their preferences.


EPrint Type:Thesis
Thesis Type:Ph. D. thesis
Keywords:ecological economics, rationality, wastewater management, agricultural systems
Subjects: Environmental aspects
Knowledge management > Research methodology and philosophy
Farming Systems
Research affiliation: Norway > NILF - Norwegian Agricultural Economics Research Institute
Norway > UMB - Norwegian University of Life Sciences
Deposited By: Refsgaard, Ph.D. Karen
ID Code:6192
Deposited On:19 Dec 2005
Last Modified:12 Apr 2010 07:31
Document Language:English
Status:Published
Refereed:Not peer-reviewed

Repository Staff Only: item control page